4 sources healthy · latest episode 9 Nov 2026
opinion claim

Joscha Bach says a functionalist would reject distinguishing a molecule from water based on an inaccessible internal difference when its observable behavior matches other water molecules.

Unresolved speaker · Why Leibniz Couldn't Find the Mind Inside the Mill (Joscha Bach) · 2 Nov 2026

In their words

The transcript segments this claim was taken from

“It's connecting to other water molecules in the same way, and so on. You can freeze it into ice in the same way. Only internally it's different, right? To a functionalist, this notion doesn't make sense because all the other water molecules have been constructed in the same way.”
1:06:15Report a misattribution
0.85how strongly it was put, not whether it is true
0.70importance to the conversation
0.93confidence the claim was read correctly