4 sources healthy · latest episode 9 Nov 2026
opinion claim

Joscha Bach rejects the argument that simulated water cannot make you wet and believes the philosophical opposition to the contrary view is driven by social rather than intellectual reasons.

Unresolved speaker · Why Leibniz Couldn't Find the Mind Inside the Mill (Joscha Bach) · 2 Nov 2026

In their words

The transcript segments this claim was taken from

“So I don't understand the argument that simulated water makes you wet. I don't understand why there is such a strong camp of simulated w- uh, water doesn't c- uh, make you wet in philosophy, and I think it has social reasons, not intellectual reasons that this is the case.”
1:09:06Report a misattribution
0.90how strongly it was put, not whether it is true
0.75importance to the conversation
0.96confidence the claim was read correctly